See all Blogs
January 14, 2025

Smart Upsell Techniques: 7 Ways to Increase Average Order Value

Smart upsell techniques on Shopify help merchants increase revenue by offering personalized product upgrades and add-ons, enhancing both sales and the shopping experience.

Why Smart Upsell Techniques Work:

  • Upselling is cheaper than acquiring new customers.
  • Relevant offers improve satisfaction and loyalty.
  • Premium upgrades increase profit margins.
  • Fewer products to manage means easier inventory control.

Get a feature comparison today!

Recharge
Other subscription apps
Hang tight while our team sends over the feature comparison report!
Oops! Try again later

In today's competitive business scene, increasing revenue is just not about finding new customers but about leveraging every encounter with a customer. Such is where Average Order Value comes in. AOV can be defined as the total amount of money spent in a single transaction by any customer. It is vital for measuring profitability, cash flow, and the all-around health of a company.

Instead of constantly seeking new customers, businesses can focus on upselling. Upselling is a strategy that encourages existing customers to buy higher-priced items, additional products, or upgrade their choices. Upselling is much cheaper than acquiring new customers. Research has it that acquiring a new customer can be five times more expensive than selling to an existing one. By mastering the art of upselling, companies can increase AOV, drive profitability, and create long-term customer relationships.

Why Focus on Upselling?

1. Cost-Efficiency of Upselling vs. Customer Acquisition

Numbers are simple; getting a new customer costs money. One has to spend on advertisement, generation of leads, and nurturing to convert the prospect into a customer. Upselling, however, targets the customer base. Customers already show intent to purchase; they are more willing to take the additional offer.

According to Marketing Metrics, the chances of selling to an existing customer are 60-70%, while selling to a new prospect has a probability of only 5-20%. In addition, businesses that have perfected upselling techniques will realize higher lifetime value per customer, as the initial investment in acquiring that customer continues to pay dividends.

2. Impact of Higher AOV on Profitability

Increasing AOV has a compounding effect on a business’s profitability. Every upsell increases the revenue without adding customer acquisition costs. More AOV also enhances cash flow which businesses can reinvest into marketing, product development, or operational growth. Therefore, raising the AOV using smart upselling techniques greatly boosts a company's bottom line.

Seven Smart Upselling Techniques

1. Product Bundling

What It Is: Product bundling is the process of combining related products and selling them at a discounted price. Instead of buying the items individually, customers receive a "deal" on the bundle.

Why It Works: Customers perceive bundles as higher value offers, which increases the likelihood of purchase.

How to Execute It:

  • Complementary Products: Bundle products that naturally go together (e.g., a phone and phone case, shampoo and conditioner).
  • Effective Pricing: The price of the bundle should be a little less than the sum of the prices of the individual items.
  • Real-World Example: Fast-food chains are very good at product bundling with their "combo meals," which feel like better deals than buying items separately.

2. Tiered Pricing Structures

What It Is: This involves offering a "good-better-best" pricing model-to give customers multiple pricing options for what is essentially the same product.

Why It Works: Customers naturally lean toward the middle option, believing it offers the best balance of price and features. This effect is known as price anchoring.

How to Execute It:

  • Provide three product or service versions: a basic version, a premium, and a high-end, or "luxury", version.
  • Highlight the benefits of the mid-tier option to make it more appealing.
  • Real-World Example: Streaming services like Netflix use tiered pricing. The “standard” plan is designed to look like the best value compared to the “basic” and “premium” plans.

3. Personalized Recommendations

What It Is: Personalized upselling employs customer data, purchase history, and browsing behavior to recommend products that are pertinent to individual customers.

Why It Works: Personalization makes customers feel understood, and they’re more likely to buy products that fit their preferences.

How to Execute It:

  • Leverage AI-driven recommendation engines, like the ones used by Amazon, to suggest "Customers also bought" products.
  • Use customer purchase history to send personalized email upsell offers.
  • Suggest products at the product pages and at the checkout stage.

Real-World Example: E-commerce giants like Amazon and Netflix use algorithms to suggest products, shows, or movies based on user preferences and past behavior.

4. Limited-Time Offers

What It Is: Urgency-based upselling involves offering customers a limited-time opportunity to upgrade their purchase or add extra items.

Why It Works: Urgency triggers FOMO (fear of missing out), which drives impulse purchases.

How to Execute It:

  • Use countdown timers on product pages.
  • Offer “Today Only” or “Flash Sale” upsells.
  • Limit the availability of the upsell offer (e.g., “Offer ends in 1 hour”).

Real-World Example: Booking platforms like Expedia and Hotels.com use limited-time offers with phrases like "Only 2 rooms left at this price!" to drive bookings.

5. Post-Purchase Upsells

What It Is: Instead of sending the upsell process to check out, businesses give them more stuff after they have already paid.

Why It Works: Once someone has committed to a purchase, they become psychologically open to accepting another offer.

How to Execute It:

  • Present post-purchase offers on the "Thank You" page.
  • Send follow-up emails with related product recommendations.
  • Offer one-click upsells using payment information saved from the original purchase.

Real-World Example: E-commerce platforms such as Shopify and WooCommerce have severaol apps to make one-click post-purchase upsells.

6. Loyalty Program Integration

What It Is: Businesses give loyalty program members preferential upsell offers, discounts, or points multipliers.

Why It Works: Loyalty program members are more engaged and motivated to maximize rewards.

How to Execute It:

  • Offer double or triple points on premium products.
  • Create exclusive upsell offers for loyalty program members.
  • Introduce VIP tiers that unlock upsell benefits, such as free shipping on higher-tier purchases.

Real-World Example: Starbucks' loyalty program offers double points days to encourage customers to spend more to earn rewards faster.

7. Cross-Sell Suggestions

What It Is: Cross-selling is the sale of complementary or related products-often during checkout.

Why It Works: Display relevant, related products and cause customers to add those products to the cart.

How to Execute It:

  • Identify frequently bought products and make recommendations on the product page.
  • Display “People Also Bought” sections on checkout pages.
  • Use cross-sell recommendations in an exit-intent pop up.

Real-World Example: Retailers such as Best Buy will offer phone accessories alongside a purchased smartphone.

Conclusion

Increasing the Average Order Value (AOV) isn’t just a "nice to have" — it’s a business growth essential. By implementing these seven smart upselling techniques, businesses can maximize revenue per customer and significantly boost profitability.

Key Takeaways:

  • Use product bundling to increase perceived value.
  • Implement tiered pricing to take advantage of price anchoring.
  • Use personalized recommendations to guide customer choices.
  • Leverage limited-time offers to create urgency.
  • Use post-purchase upsells to increase sales after checkout.
  • Upsell alongside loyalty programs for greater interaction.
  • Provide cross-selling options to add more to a cart.

Action Steps for Implementation:

  1. Audit your website or e-commerce store to identify potential upsell opportunities.
  2. Take advantage of software applications like an AI-based recommendation system
  3. Train the sales and customer support groups on the art of upselling
  4. Continuously calculate and enhance your AOV growth strategy.

By mastering these upselling tactics, businesses can get more meaningful relationships with the customers while maximizing revenue. Higher AOV means higher profits, and that is a win-win for both parties: businesses and customers.

TRY FOR FREE
Share article link
Written by
Emma Johnson
Head of Marketing

Emma Johnson is celebrated for her strategic brilliance and innovative flair. By seamlessly blending creativity with data-driven insights, she has propelled Loop’s brand to new heights, establishing it as a formidable force in the Shopify Subscriptions space.